Obama campaign takes fire over church conference speech

Sen. Obama's speech at last summer's United Church of Christ conference has managed to pull an IRS investigation according to the AP. Here's some interesting analysis from two sources:

John Wilson's IRS Probe Of Obama's Church Underscores Anxieties For Nonprofits underscores the difficulty charities and other nonprofits are facing with these subjective rules... something I've blogged about before.

Over at the Nonprofit Law Prof blog, there's a a great pointer to Jack Siegel's take on the situation. Quoting their quote of him:

We do think Congress must step in and write a prohibition on political campaign activity that addresses the reality of how churches and other Section 501(c)(3) organizations interact with political candidates. In addressing this problem, we would like to see Congress take an approach akin to that taken by the intermediate sanctions in Section 4958. That is, rather than penalizing the innocent entity or the entity that can't control a speaker once the speech has begun, the sanctions should focus on the speaker's conduct, penalizing the speaker. Many will argue that this raises First Amendment issues. We recognize that possibility, but are not convinced. Obviously, the speaker has a right to speak, but the speech in question is by invitation. Consequently, this is not silencing the speaker in terms of access to the public square.

A safe harbor for the charity in case the speaker slips into campaign mode would probably face a lot less resistance compared to the flip side: penalizing the speaker. I'd be very surprised if that idea ever got off the ground.

Law schools

I got a question in my email box from a prospective law student... unfortunately the student's email bounced back on me so I couldn't respond! So, if you fit that bill... email me at tim at tim dash mooney dot com and I'll resend it to you directly.

A lot of people ask me about how to go about training to become a lawyer serving nonprofits... I think the bottom line is that law schools are - for the most part - not the place where you'll learn that craft. There are absolutely some great programs out there (Columbia and Boston College come to mind immediately) but I've always maintained that no matter what type of law you'd like to practice, you want to find a good clinical program rather than seek out the best academic program. I'm sure others may disagree, but I can honestly say I learned far more about being a lawyer in my litigation clinic than in any of my classes.

One major piece of advice I give to anyone thinking about nonprofit work in law school... take administrative law. You'll be shocked how often it's relevant to the work you do!

Candidate accused of misusing charity

A North Carolina state representative is being accused of using her charity's resources to aid in her election efforts. Rep. Mary McAllister helped found Operation Sickle Cell in 1972 and has found herself the target of a state auditor's investigation. More on this from the Fayetteville Observer.

Interesting to see that it is a state investigation... it's conceivable that the IRS could look into this as well.

Look out FEC... here comes another lawsuit

Happy Valentine's Day FEC! SpeechNow.org is filing a lawsuit against the FEC today, asking a federal court to allow it to advocate for or against federal candidates without having to comply with contribution limits. The way things have been going in these cases, the SpeechNow.org argument has a really strong chance of succeeding... it takes no corporate money and it does not coordinate with federal candidates nor make contributions to federal candidates. It's (kind of... sort of) akin to the successful arguments made decades ago in MCFL. If that rings a bell, that case opened things up for certain types of ideological 501(c)(4) organizations to make independent expenditures.

In any event, pay attention to this one if you want your nonprofit to be able to engage in more election-related advocacy. It's got a lot of election lawyers taking notice.

OC Church under IRS investigation

Memo to all 501(c)(3)s (especially churches)... yes, the head of your organization can endorse a candidate. Just be sure to not use the organization letterhead when you do it... it matters (apparently) to the IRS.

As I write this, I'm thinking about the paradox in IRS rules at times... in what I like to call the "hang a lantern on your problem" rule, the IRS has no problem when an endorsing person is listed with their organizational affiliation along with an asterisk that leads the reader to a disclaimer stating "organizational affiliation listed for identification purposes only." (IRS FS-2006-17) Contrast that with this instance where clear organizational identification (the letterhead) seems to be leading this church into an investigation even though the pastor is suggesting that the letter underscored a personal endorsement. I think you can distinguish the two endorsement scenarios, but it underscores a continuing problem for all 501(c)(3)s out there: the facts and circumstances analysis is so subjective that it's sometimes difficult to know where the line is between legal and illegal activity.

Nonprofits and elections

BoardSource has just released a new article by my former boss, John Pomeranz entitled
Staying Legal While Engaging in Election-Related Activities. It's free for BoardSource members, but you can check out a free portion of the article here.

Since it's a timely subject, be sure to check out the latest in the Nonprofit Law Podcast's Beyond the Podcast series... Nonprofits and Elections: Balancing Personal Versus Organizational Activity. It's an on-demand video you can get through the NLP site here.

Nonprofit Law Podcast #31: Do we have to file a 990?

Nonprofit Law Podcast #31 is live, covering whether your organization needs to file a Form 990 this year.

One-click subscribe in iTunes
Subscribe in other podcatchers

When the IRS will audit your nonprofit

The IRS recently released Fact Sheet 2008-14, in which it spelled out when your nonprofit might be considered for an examination of its activities:

To determine which organizations should be targeted, experienced specialists analyze information from Forms 990 and other sources. This analysis will usually result in the selection of a group of returns for examination or compliance check. EO also reviews media reports and receives complaints from the general public and Congress about potential non-compliance by exempt organizations. After confirming the information, and when appropriate, these organizations may be selected for examination or to receive a compliance check.

This isn't terribly earth-shattering news... basically the IRS says that it looks at 990s, media reports and complaints, which most in the community already assumed. It's good to have it documented officially, however.

Nonprofit Law Podcast #30: Can a candidate use our space?

Nonprofit Law Podcast #30 dives into election waters again - can a candidate use your nonprofit's space?

One-click subscribe in iTunes
Subscribe in other podcatchers